Psychology

What is Mistake Log?

Reviewed by Karthikeyan Anbarasan (Founder, TradeLyser) · Updated 19 Oct 2026 · Editorial policy

DefinitionA mistake log is a record of every trade where you broke a rule or made an execution error, with the type of mistake and what it cost in rupees. Moving a stop on a Nifty call from ₹95 to ₹80 and exiting at ₹78 instead of ₹95 cost (₹95 − ₹78) × 65 = ₹1,105 more than the plan (illustrative).
Formula
Cost of a mistake = P&L if the rule had been followed − Actual P&L; Monthly cost = Sum across all logged mistakes
Example
Entry ₹118, planned stop ₹95, exit ₹78, lot 65: −₹1,495 − (−₹2,600) = ₹1,105 extra loss from the moved stop
85%92%+₹14kWk 188%+₹9kWk 261%−₹12kWk 395%+₹11kWk 470%−₹6kWk 590%+₹7kWk 655%−₹15kWk 793%+₹12kWk 8
Figure 1. Illustrative eight weeks of rule adherence (bars) and net P&L (dots). The five weeks at 85% adherence or above made +₹53k in total; the three weeks below 75% came to −₹33k. A mistake log shows which broken rules sat behind those three weeks.

A loss is not a mistake

Planned loss

The setup was valid, the size was right and the stop was honoured. It does not go in the mistake log.
Cost of doing business

Rule break

You did something your plan forbids: moved a stop, oversized, traded without a setup, ignored the daily limit.
Behaviour mistake

Execution error

Wrong strike, wrong expiry, wrong quantity or wrong product type. Often a process or checklist problem.
Mechanical mistake

Winning trades go in the log too when a rule was broken. A trade at three times planned size that happened to make money is still a sizing mistake, and it is the one most likely to be repeated.

A short, fixed list of categories

Mistake typeExample (illustrative)How to price it
Moved stopStop moved from ₹95 to ₹80Actual loss minus the loss at the original stop
Oversize3 lots taken, plan allowed 1P&L on the extra lots
No setupEntry with no playbook tagWhole P&L of the trade
Revenge re-entryNew trade within minutes of a stop-outWhole P&L of the trade
Ignored daily limitKept trading after −₹6,000P&L after the limit was hit
Early exitClosed at +0.5R with a 2R planProfit given up; keep separate from realised costs
Execution errorBought the monthly expiry instead of the weeklyDifference from the intended order

A worked month

MistakeCountCost
Revenge re-entry3−₹9,100
Moved stop4−₹4,420
Oversize2−₹3,900
Early exit (profit given up)6₹5,850 not captured
Realised cost of mistakes
−₹17,420
Profit given up by early exits
₹5,850
Most frequent
Early exit
Most costly
Revenge

The three revenge trades (−₹3,900, +₹2,600 and −₹7,800) cost more than the six early exits, even though early exits happened twice as often. Ranking by rupees rather than by count points to the rule worth writing first, such as a 30-minute pause after any stop-out.

Reviewing the log

  1. Log the mistake the same day, with one primary type and the rupee cost worked out as above.
  2. Each Friday, rank mistake types by total cost for the week and for the month to date.
  3. Pick the single costliest type and write one specific rule that would have prevented it.
  4. Check the same mistake type four weeks later: did the count and the cost fall?
  5. Keep the list of types short and fixed, so counts can be compared month to month.
For F&O traders in India
Execution errors with weekly and monthly expiries are common: Nifty weekly options expire every Tuesday, while Bank Nifty, FinNifty and stock F&O expire on the last Tuesday of the month. Also log wrong product types, such as intraday instead of carry-forward. Examples use a Nifty lot of 65; check the current NSE circular.

Reference guide

ContextValueReading
Every mistake logged the same day with a rupee costUsable logYou can rank mistakes by what they cost, not by how they felt
Normal losing trades logged as mistakesMixed-up logA loss inside the plan is not a mistake; logging it hides the real errors
Long list of fixes every weekNothing changesPick the single costliest mistake and write one rule for it

Questions

What should a trading mistake log include?

The date, the trade, the type of mistake from a fixed list, what the plan said, what you did, and the rupee cost compared with following the plan.

How do I calculate the cost of a trading mistake?

Subtract your actual P&L from the P&L you would have had by following the rule. For a moved stop, that is the actual loss minus the loss at the original stop.

Is a losing trade a mistake?

Not if the setup was valid, the size was correct and the stop was honoured. That is a planned loss. A winning trade can be a mistake if it broke a rule.

How often should I review my mistake log?

Log daily and review weekly. Rank mistakes by total rupee cost, fix one at a time, and recheck it after about four weeks.

Related terms