What is Trade Replay?
Reviewed by Karthikeyan Anbarasan (Founder, TradeLyser) · Updated 19 Oct 2026 · Editorial policy
How a replay works
- Open the trade from the journal, so the chart starts on the right date, instrument and time.
- Start a few bars before the entry, with everything to the right hidden.
- Step forward one bar at a time. At each decision point (entry, stop placement, any add, the exit) pause and write what the plan said.
- Mark where your action and the plan diverged, and what you saw or felt at that bar.
- Tag the trade (late-entry, early-exit, moved-stop or clean) and write one line on what to repeat or change.
The point of hiding the future is to recreate the decision you faced. Live, you saw only the bars up to that moment, with money on the line and the clock running. A replay cannot bring back the pressure, but it can stop you from using information you did not have. Each pause should answer two questions: what did the plan say here, and did I do it? Whether the next bar went your way is a separate matter, and the journal’s P&L already records it.
Worked example: an early exit
Illustrative plan: buy the Nifty 25,100 call when a 5-minute Nifty candle closes above the opening range high, stop ₹30 below the entry premium, and trail the stop once the trade reaches +1R. One lot of 65 (check the current NSE circular). Premiums are illustrative and before charges.
| Bar | Plan said | What happened | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9:40 candle | Wait for the candle to close above the range high | Bought at ₹142 at 9:41, while the candle was still forming; it closed with the premium at ₹136 | C |
| 9:45 | Stop ₹30 below entry | Stop placed at ₹112 | A |
| 9:52 | Hold until +1R, then trail | Sold at ₹150 on the first red candle, +₹8 a unit | C |
| 10:05 | Trail | Premium reached ₹171, after the exit | For context only |
The result works out as (₹150 − ₹142) × 65 = ₹520. The replay does not say the trade should have made ₹1,365 more: at the 9:52 bar nobody knew where the premium would go next. What it does show is that both departures from the plan, the early entry and the early exit, came from not waiting. That is the one thing to carry into the Friday review, tagged on the trade so it can be counted.
Trade replay vs backtesting
Trade replay
Backtesting
Getting value from replay
- Replay the worst trade every Friday; the 15-minute weekly review gives it four minutes.
- Replay rule breaks before winners. A clean loss needs little time; an oversized one needs the most.
- For options, look at the underlying as well as the premium, since the plan’s trigger is usually on the underlying.
- Count replay tags once a month. If late-entry keeps appearing, that is the rule to work on next.
- Do not redesign a strategy after replaying one trade. A strategy change needs 30 or more trades behind it.
Reference guide
| Context | Value | Reading |
|---|---|---|
| Bars to the right hidden while replaying | Fair review | Each decision is judged with what was on the screen at the time |
| Whole chart visible from the start | Hindsight | Every exit looks early and every stop looks obvious; step forward one bar at a time |
| Only winners replayed | Skewed | Start with the worst trade and the rule breaks, as the Friday review does |
Questions
What is trade replay in trading?
Reviewing a trade you have already taken by stepping through its chart one candle at a time, pausing at each decision to compare what you did with what the plan said.
How is trade replay different from backtesting?
Replay looks at trades you actually took to improve execution. Backtesting runs a set of rules over historical data to see whether the strategy itself has an edge.
Which trades should I replay?
The worst trade of the week, any trade that broke a rule, and outlier wins. Routine trades that followed the plan need only the short post-trade note.
Can I replay my trades in TradeLyser?
Yes. Trade Replay opens any synced NSE or BSE trade from the journal and steps through price action candle by candle, with pause and rewind. Notes, screenshots and tags added during replay are saved on the trade.
How do I avoid hindsight bias when replaying trades?
Hide the bars to the right of where you are, step forward one at a time and write what the plan said before revealing the next bar. Grade the decision, not the outcome.