What is Trading Journal?
Reviewed by Karthikeyan Anbarasan (Founder, TradeLyser) · Updated 19 Oct 2026 · Editorial policy
What to record for each trade
| Field | Example (illustrative) | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Instrument and product | Nifty 25,000 CE, intraday | Options, futures and cash behave differently and need separate numbers |
| Setup tag | Opening range breakout | Lets you work out expectancy per setup |
| Planned stop and size | Stop ₹30 below entry, 1 lot | Shows whether a loss stayed inside the plan |
| Net P&L after charges | −₹2,140 | Gross figures flatter small, frequent trades |
| Rules followed | 6 of 7 | Feeds the discipline score |
| One-line note | Entered before the candle closed | The context the numbers cannot show |
Prices, quantities and charges are already known to your broker. The setup, the plan and the note are the parts only you can add, and they are what make the record useful when you filter it months later.
- Chart screenshot at entry, with the trigger level marked, so the trade can be replayed without hindsight.
- Entry and exit time, which later lets you split results by time of day and by expiry day.
- R-multiple: the result divided by the planned risk. A −₹2,140 loss on ₹1,950 of planned risk is about −1.1R, which shows the stop slipped.
- Market context in a word or two: gap up, trend day, range day, event day.
- A mood or energy score from 1 to 5, written before the session and again after it.
Tags that make the journal searchable
| Tag family | Examples | Question it answers |
|---|---|---|
| Setup | ORB, VWAP reclaim, breakout retest, short straddle | Which setups actually make money after charges? |
| Mistake | FOMO, revenge, moved stop, oversized, early exit | Which error costs the most each month? |
| Context | Expiry Tuesday, gap open, RBI policy day, Budget day | Do some days need different rules? |
| State | Tired, distracted, after a loss, confident | Does how you feel change how you trade? |
A month of tagged trades, worked through
Illustrative month of 40 Nifty option trades, net after charges. Eighteen opening range breakout trades made +₹21,600, or +₹1,200 per trade. Twelve VWAP reclaim trades made +₹4,800, or +₹400 per trade. Ten trades carried no setup tag, and most also carried a FOMO or revenge tag; they lost ₹13,900, or −₹1,390 per trade. The month closed at +₹12,500.
The broker statement shows only the +₹12,500. The journal shows that the untagged trades took back more than half of what the two setups earned, so the change for next month is a rule against untagged entries, not a new strategy. Twelve VWAP trades are too few to judge, so that setup stays at its current size until it reaches 30.
Turning the journal into decisions
- After the close, check that every trade from the day is in the journal, including the ones you would rather forget.
- Tag each trade with its setup and grade it A, B or C on process, not on profit.
- On Friday, read net P&L next to rule adherence for the week and write down one change.
- Once a month, compare expectancy per setup over at least 30 trades before keeping, resizing or pausing it.
| Review | When | What you look at | What comes out of it |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 minutes | After every session | All trades logged, setup tags, A/B/C grade, one line on mood | A complete, honest record of the day |
| 15 minutes | Every Friday | Net P&L, adherence %, the worst trade replayed, mistake tag counts | One written change for next week |
| 45 minutes | Once a month | Expectancy per setup, max drawdown against limits, context tags | Keep, resize or pause each setup |
Journal templates worth keeping
- Pre-market plan: bias, key levels, events on the calendar, the day’s loss limit and the setups you are allowed to take.
- Trade entry: setup tag, trigger, stop, size, planned risk in ₹, screenshot and one line on why.
- End-of-day recap (the 3-minute review): trades logged, grades, rules broken, mood after the session.
- Weekly review (the 15-minute review): net P&L, adherence %, mistake tag counts, worst trade, one change.
- Monthly review (the 45-minute review): expectancy and win rate per setup, max drawdown, context tags, keep, resize or pause.
- Mistake post-mortem: for any trade that broke a rule, what happened, what triggered it and the rule that would have stopped it.
Using the same templates every time matters more than which ones you choose, because only consistent fields can be compared across months. TradeLyser lets you save review templates and create custom tags, so the same fields appear at every review.
Journal vs broker trade book
Broker trade book
Trading journal
| Question | Broker P&L statement | Trading journal |
|---|---|---|
| What did I make this month? | Yes, realised P&L and charges | Yes, and it should match the broker |
| Which setup makes money? | No, it has no setup field | Yes, by setup tag |
| Did I keep to my stop and size? | No, it has no plan to compare with | Yes, planned vs actual |
| Are expiry Tuesdays worse for me? | Only by sorting dates by hand | Yes, by context tag |
| What do I file for tax? | Yes, the source for tax figures | No, use the broker statement |
A broker P&L statement often lists results by contract and day, while a journal groups fills into trades. Each month, check that the journal’s net total matches the broker’s realised P&L after charges. A gap usually means a trade, a charge or a partial exit is missing from the journal.
Reference guide
| Context | Value | Reading |
|---|---|---|
| Logged the same day | Reliable record | Prices come from the broker; reasons are written while you still remember them |
| Filled in from memory at the weekend | Weak record | Losing trades and impulse entries are the ones that get left out |
| Logged but never reviewed | Unused data | Book a fixed review slot; a journal pays off only when it changes a rule |
Questions
What should a trading journal include?
At minimum: instrument, entry and exit, size, net P&L after charges, the setup, whether you followed your rules and a short note. A chart screenshot at entry helps when you replay the trade later.
Is Excel good enough for a trading journal?
It can work if every trade gets logged and reviewed. The weak points are typing errors, charges left out and days skipped when entry takes too long; a journal that imports fills from the broker removes the typing and leaves you the tags and notes.
How often should I review my trading journal?
A practical rhythm is 3 minutes after every session, 15 minutes each Friday and 45 minutes once a month. The daily check keeps the record complete; the weekly and monthly reviews are where rules change.
How many trades before a journal shows anything useful?
Results per setup start to mean something after about 30 trades and are more dependable near 100. Rule adherence is useful from the first day, because it does not depend on sample size.
What is the difference between a trading journal and a broker P&L statement?
The broker statement records what was traded, the realised P&L and the charges, and it is the source for tax. A journal adds why each trade was taken, its setup, the plan and whether rules were followed, which is what lets you decide what to change.
What tags should I use in a trading journal?
Start with four small families: setup (ORB, VWAP reclaim), mistake (FOMO, revenge, moved stop), context (expiry Tuesday, gap open) and state (tired, after a loss). Fix the names in advance so filters stay clean.