What is Strategy Scorecard?
Reviewed by Karthikeyan Anbarasan (Founder, TradeLyser) · Updated 19 Oct 2026 · Editorial policy
What goes on a scorecard
| Metric | What it tells you | Read it with |
|---|---|---|
| Trades | How much evidence there is | Below about 30, treat everything as provisional |
| Win rate | How often the strategy wins | Average win and average loss |
| Average win and loss (R) | How big wins are compared with losses | Win rate |
| Expectancy (R) | Average result per trade | Trade count |
| Profit factor | Gross profit ÷ gross loss | Expectancy |
| Maximum drawdown (R) | The worst peak-to-trough fall | The limit you set for that strategy |
| Rule adherence | Share of trades that followed every rule | Separates strategy problems from execution problems |
A worked scorecard
| Metric | Opening range breakout | VWAP reclaim | Expiry-day scalps |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trades | 84 | 41 | 63 |
| Wins / losses | 37 / 47 | 19 / 22 | 35 / 28 |
| Win rate | 44.0% | 46.3% | 55.6% |
| Average win | 2.0R | 1.4R | 0.6R |
| Average loss | 1.0R | 1.0R | 1.15R |
| Expectancy | +0.32R | +0.11R | −0.18R |
| Profit factor | 1.57 | 1.21 | 0.65 |
| Net result at ₹2,000 per R | +₹54,000 | +₹9,200 | −₹22,400 |
| Maximum drawdown | 6.0R | 4.5R | 13.2R |
| Rule adherence | 91% | 88% | 64% |
Illustrative, after charges. The scalps have the best win rate and the worst result: 35 wins of 0.6R make 21R, while 28 losses of 1.15R cost 32.2R, a net of −11.2R. Their adherence of 64% says part of the problem is execution, so the scorecard points to two questions, not one. The VWAP reclaim has a positive expectancy over 41 trades, but its profit factor of 1.21 leaves little room for higher costs or slippage. The opening range breakout earns most of the total from fewer than half of the trades.
Read across the rows rather than down a single column. Sorting by win rate would put the scalps first; sorting by net result or expectancy puts them last, which is where they belong. The drawdown row adds a second view of risk: the scalps fell 13.2R from a peak at their worst, more than twice the breakout’s 6.0R, while making less. A sensible monthly decision from this card is to keep the breakout, keep the VWAP reclaim at its current size while it builds more trades, and pause the scalps until their rule adherence improves and a paper test shows a positive result. The scorecard does not make that decision for you, but it makes the evidence for it visible on one page.
Building and updating it
- Tag every trade with one strategy or setup, so each row has its own trades.
- Measure every result in R, using the planned risk at entry, so strategies of different sizes compare fairly.
- Use the same metrics and the same date range for every strategy on the card.
- Update it once a month, in the 45-minute monthly review, not after every losing day.
- Write a keep, resize or pause decision beside each row, with the trade count it was based on.
Where scorecards mislead
- One outsized winner can carry a whole row; check the expectancy without the best trade.
- Different date ranges make strategies look better or worse depending on the market phase they covered.
- Strategies that trade at the same time are not independent; two rows can lose together on the same day.
- A single drawdown figure hides how long the strategy stayed underwater; add the longest run of sessions below the previous peak if you can.
- Averages hide change over time; compare each row’s last 30 trades with its full history to see whether the edge is fading.
Strategy scorecard vs edge audit
Strategy scorecard
Edge audit
Reference guide
| Context | Value | Reading |
|---|---|---|
| Every strategy shows its trade count next to its numbers | Honest comparison | A great-looking strategy with 12 trades is not compared on equal terms with one that has 84 |
| Strategies ranked by win rate | Misleading | A high win rate with small wins and large losses can lose money; rank by expectancy |
| Scorecard built on gross P&L | Costs hidden | Use results after charges; frequent strategies pay the most in costs |
Questions
What is a strategy scorecard in trading?
A table showing the same metrics for each strategy you trade, such as trades, win rate, average win and loss, expectancy, profit factor and drawdown, so you can compare them fairly.
Which metrics matter most on a strategy scorecard?
Expectancy with the trade count beside it, then win rate and average win and loss to explain it, and maximum drawdown against your limit. Rule adherence shows whether a weak row is a strategy or an execution problem.
How is expectancy calculated for a strategy?
Expectancy = (win rate × average win) − (loss rate × average loss), in R. With a 44% win rate, 2R average win and 1R average loss: 0.88R − 0.56R = +0.32R per trade.
What is a good profit factor for a strategy?
Above 1 means gross profits exceed gross losses. Many traders look for comfortably above 1, since a thin margin can disappear after charges and slippage, and the figure only means much after about 30 trades.
How often should I update my strategy scorecard?
Monthly, as part of the monthly review. Updating it after every session encourages decisions on too few trades.