Step 2 of 5

Strategies: one tag for each trading edge

Tag every trade to a written playbook so win rate, expectancy and drawdown are measured per setup instead of blended across the account.

Karthikeyan Anbarasan

Founder, TradeLyser

Reviewed by Shankar Gajendran (CTO, TradeLyser) · Updated 18 Oct 2026 · 5 min read

What a strategy tag can tell you, by trade count

  • One strategy tag means one entry trigger, one stop rule and one exit plan.
  • Wait for 20 closed trades on a tag before you increase its size.
  • Retire a tag only after a fair sample, and keep its history.

A strategy tag says that a group of trades shared one entry trigger, one stop rule and one exit plan. Put a Bank Nifty opening-range breakout and a multi-day pullback trade under the same tag, and the win rate you get describes neither of them.

Tags exist so expectancy, profit factor and drawdown are measured per playbook. The account total still matters for risk, but it cannot tell you which setup is paying for which.

What makes a separate strategy

Two trades belong under one tag only if they share the entry trigger, the stop placement and the exit logic. If two tags differ only by symbol, merge them. If one tag holds both bought options and credit spreads, split it, because the risk is different.

  1. Name the strategy by what you do, such as "Nifty ORB long", not "Morning trades".
  2. Write the entry trigger in one sentence that someone else could follow.
  3. Write where the stop goes and how size is worked out from it.
  4. Write the exit: a target, a trailing rule or a time stop.
  5. List the instruments and session times it applies to. Anything outside that list gets a different tag, or no trade.
Strategy Map tab on a single trade in TradeLyser, with a strategy selected, a list of its rules with three of nine ticked, and a confidence score and note field for each rule
Figure 1. The Strategy Map tab on a trade: pick the strategy, tick which of its rules applied, and add a confidence score and a note for each rule.

Why blended numbers mislead

An illustrative month on Bank Nifty, with ₹2,000 risked per trade as 1R. Tag A, opening-range breakout longs: 24 trades, expectancy +0.22R, profit factor 1.45. Tag B, afternoon fade shorts: 19 trades, expectancy −0.15R, profit factor 0.82.

Tag A: 24 × +0.22R
+₹10,560
Tag B: 19 × −0.15R
−₹5,700
Account for the month
+₹4,860

The account shows a modest green month and nothing looks wrong. Split by tag, the decision is clear: keep A at full risk, and pause B until its entry is rewritten. Without the split, B quietly takes back more than half of what A earns.

Common mistake
Comparing win rate across tags with different targets. A 38% win rate on a setup that wins 3R and loses 1R earns +0.52R per trade, while 62% on a 1:1 setup earns +0.24R. Compare expectancy first.

Sample size before you change size

Do not add size to a tag until it has 20 closed trades taken in similar conditions. Ten trades can reveal a disaster, such as a setup that fails almost every time, but not an edge. On Nifty weekly options, 20 trades of one setup can take several expiry cycles, so plan for that instead of judging after four trades.

0%50%100%10 trades±31 pts30 trades±18 pts100 trades±10 pts300 trades±6 pts
Figure 2. How uncertain a 50% win rate is at different sample sizes (95% range): ±31 points after 10 trades, ±18 after 30, ±10 after 100 and ±6 after 300.
Rule of thumb
Twenty closed trades before any size increase, and forty before you retire a tag. Safety rules such as a daily loss cap apply from the first trade.

The monthly strategy pass

On the first weekend of the month, look at each live tag: expectancy in R after charges, profit factor, maximum drawdown, trade count and how often its rules were followed. Then make one call per tag.

Keep

Positive expectancy after charges over 20 or more trades, with rules mostly followed. Same risk next month.

Resize

Positive but in a deep drawdown, or the sample is still small. Halve the risk and keep collecting trades.

Pause or retire

Still negative after 40 trades and one rule revision. Archive the tag and keep its history.
Strategy performance page for a breakout strategy in TradeLyser showing total P&L, win rate, profit factor, max drawdown, Sharpe ratio, trade statistics and a monthly performance chart
Figure 3. One strategy's detail page: total P&L, win rate, profit factor, max drawdown, Sharpe ratio and monthly performance for that tag alone.

Tagging F&O trades

  • Give each structure its own tag: option buying, option selling, spreads and hedges.
  • Mark expiry-day trades. Nifty weekly options expire on Tuesday, and theta trades on that day are not comparable with directional trades on other days.
  • Keep paper trades on separate tags. When a setup goes live, its live sample starts from zero.
  • Archive tags you stop trading instead of deleting them. The history helps if the setup comes back.
  • Read profit factor after charges. On small scalps, STT and brokerage can turn 1.1 into breakeven.

Copy the strategy definition

Strategy name: ___
Instruments and session: ___
Entry trigger (one sentence): ___
Stop placement: ___
Size: risk ₹___ per trade; quantity = risk ÷ stop distance
Exit: target ___ / trailing rule ___ / time stop ___
Not allowed with this tag: ___
First review after: 20 closed trades

Questions traders ask

How many strategies should a retail trader run?

One to three live tags is plenty. More tags usually means trades with no common entry logic filed under new names. Get one setup to 20 trades before adding another.

Can I compare win rate across strategies?

Only once each tag has 20 or more trades, and even then compare expectancy and profit factor first. Win rate alone misleads when the setups have different reward-to-risk ratios.

Should F&O structures share one tag?

No. Option buying, option selling, spreads and hedges carry different risks. If they share a tag, the reports will mix theta decay with directional results and neither number will mean much.

Terms used on this page