General

What is Execution Grade?

Reviewed by Karthikeyan Anbarasan (Founder, TradeLyser) · Updated 19 Oct 2026 · Editorial policy

DefinitionAn execution grade is a letter, usually A, B or C, that you give each trade for how closely you followed your plan on entry, size, stop and exit, whatever the result. An illustrative Nifty option trade stopped out for −₹1,950 exactly as planned is an A; a +₹3,900 winner taken at two lots instead of one is a C.
PROCESS: FOLLOWED PLANPROCESS: BROKE A RULEWonLostEarned winFollowed plan · won14 trades+₹42,000Lucky winBroke a rule · won6 trades+₹9,000Bad luckFollowed plan · lost12 trades−₹18,000Earned lossBroke a rule · lost8 trades−₹26,00026 trades · net +₹24,00014 trades · net −₹17,000Column total
Figure 1. Illustrative month of 40 trades sorted by process and outcome: followed the plan and won, 14 trades, +₹42,000; broke a rule and won, 6 trades, +₹9,000; followed the plan and lost, 12 trades, −₹18,000; broke a rule and lost, 8 trades, −₹26,000. Followed-plan trades net +₹24,000 and rule breaks net −₹17,000.

A simple A/B/C scale

CheckQuestion to answer yes or no
SetupDid the entry match a written setup on your checklist?
EntryWas the order placed at or near the planned trigger?
SizeWas the quantity what the stop and risk-per-trade rule allowed?
StopWas the stop placed with the order and left where it was, or only tightened?
ExitDid the exit come from the stop, the target or the planned trail?
A: five of five
Every check passed. A losing A trade is the cost of running the setup.
B: four of five
One minor slip on entry or exit, with size and stop intact.
C: three or fewer, or any size or stop break
Oversizing or a moved stop is a C whatever the other checks say, because it changes the risk you took.

What the grades show: a worked example

Take Figure 1 and read the followed-plan column as A and B trades and the rule-break column as C trades. The 26 A and B trades made +₹24,000, an average of about +₹923 a trade. The 14 C trades lost ₹17,000, about −₹1,214 a trade. The month finished at +₹7,000. The C trades include 6 winners worth ₹9,000, which is exactly why grading by result would have hidden the problem. Dropping the C trades would not simply have added ₹17,000 to the month, because the lucky wins would have gone too. But as a group they lost money, and they are the part of the month that was fully under your control. Grades turn a vague feeling of "I traded badly" into a count and a rupee figure you can track week by week.

A and B trades (26)
+₹24,000
C trades (14)
−₹17,000
Average per C trade
−₹1,214
Month
+₹7,000

Using grades in your review

  1. Grade each trade in the 3-minute session check, from the five checks, before you look at its P&L.
  2. On Friday, count the C trades and total their net P&L. Mark any day where the grades and the P&L disagree.
  3. Once a month, compare expectancy for A, B and C trades over the whole month, per setup where the sample allows.
  4. Pick the check that fails most often and make it the one change for next week.
  5. Now and then, have a mentor or trading partner grade a sample of your trades from the five checks alone, and compare their grades with yours to catch generous self-grading.
Rule of thumb
If C trades are more than about one in ten, work on execution before changing any strategy. A strategy cannot be judged on trades that did not follow it. A C trade that made money still counts as a C; it is the one most likely to be repeated.

Execution grade vs setup quality

Setup quality

Rated before entry: how cleanly the chart matches the setup and how many conditions line up.
Question: was this a good opportunity?

Execution grade

Rated after the trade: whether entry, size, stop and exit followed the plan.
Question: did I trade it as planned?

Keep the two separate. A marginal setup traded exactly to plan is still an A for execution, and the monthly numbers will tell you whether marginal setups are worth taking. A strong setup taken at double size is still a C. Over a few months, a simple table of setup quality against execution grade shows where your money is made and where it leaks.

For F&O traders in India
Fast premiums on Nifty weekly expiry Tuesdays make late entries and moved stops more likely, so read expiry-day grades separately. Slippage on a thin option strike is not an execution error if the order type and size followed the plan; log it as slippage instead. The free Post-Trade Review Template records planned vs actual entry, whether the stop was honoured and whether the checklist was used, which covers most of the grade checks.

Reference guide

ContextValueReading
Grades given from yes-or-no checks, the same dayHonest gradingThe grade reflects what you did, not how the trade turned out
Every winner an A, every loser a COutcome gradingThat is P&L with letters; grade the process before looking at the result
Ten grade levels with half-stepsToo fineThree levels are easier to apply the same way every day

Questions

What is an execution grade in trading?

A letter, usually A, B or C, that rates how closely a trade followed your plan on setup, entry, size, stop and exit. It ignores whether the trade made money.

Can a losing trade get an A grade?

Yes. A trade that met the setup, used the planned size and stopped out at the planned level is an A. The loss is the normal cost of trading the setup.

How do I grade my trades?

Answer five yes-or-no checks: setup, entry, size, stop and exit. All five is an A, four is a B, and three or fewer, or any size or stop break, is a C.

Should I use A/B/C or a 1 to 5 score?

Either works if you apply it the same way every day. Three levels are easier to keep consistent, and consistency matters more than precision.

How is an execution grade different from a discipline score?

An execution grade rates one trade. A discipline score rates a day or week: rules followed out of rules checked, including limits such as maximum trades and daily loss.

Related terms